Non-Scholarship Era Only
| Points | 46 | Shane Buck | Austin College | 2/3/1996 |
| FG Made | 15 | Shane Buck | Austin College | 2/3/1996 |
| FG Attempted | 29 | Matt Addison | Concordia | 1/22/2011 |
| FG Percentage | 1.000 | By many | ||
| 3-FG Made | 9 | Carlos Singer | Howard Payne | 2/11/2010 |
| 3-FG Attempted | 18 | Matt Addison | Mary Hardin-Baylor | 1/20/2011 |
| 3-FG Percentage | .857 (6-7) | Grant Justus | Sul Ross State | 2/5/2004 |
| FT Made | 18 | Shane Buck, Matt Addison | Austin College, Howard Payne | 2/3/1996, 2/19/2011 |
| FT Attempted | 21 | Shane Buck, Matt Addison | Austin College, Howard Payne | 2/3/1996, 2/19/2011 |
| FT Percentage | 1.000 (15-15) | Matt Addison | McMurry | 1/30/2012 |
| Rebounds | 22 | Mardochee Jean (2) | Schreiner, Louisiana College | 2/2/2006, 11/30/2006 |
| Assists | 12 | Rob Yoder | Austin College | 2/19/1994 |
| Blocks | 10 | Mardochee Jean | McMurry | 12/12/2005 |
| Steals | 8 | Brad Waters/Casey Riddle/MattAddison | Schreiner, LC, Huston-Tillotson | 2/6/1999, 1/6/2011, 11/16/2010 |