| Opponent | W-L-T | Last Meeting |
| Abilene Christian | 0-3-0 | L, 21-7 in 1963 |
| Air Force (Second) | 0-1-0 | L, 13-7 in 1942 |
| Amarillo | 0-0-1 | T, 13-13 in 1934 |
| Arkansas | 0-3-0 | L, 49-7 in 1962 |
| Arizona | 6-4-0 | L, 53-7 in 1961 |
| Arizona State | 13-8-0 | L, 47-0 in 1961 |
| Arlington State | 0-1-0 | L, 7-6 in 1962 |
| Auburn | 0-1-0 | L, 35-12 in 1959 |
| Austin College | 20-7-1 | W, 31-7 in 2005 |
| Azusa Pacific | 2-0-0 | W, 30-17 in 1998 |
| Baylor | 1-13-0 | L, 14-7 in 1958 |
| Catholic | 1-0-0 | W, 27-19 in 1940 |
| Central Washington | 0-1-0 | L, 40-20 in 1995 |
| Centenary | 3-1-0 | W, 27-6 in 1941 |
| Chapman | 2-0-0 | W, 48-19 in 1998 |
| Cincinnati | 1-5-1 | L, 15-14 in 1960 |
| Coe | 1-0-0 | W, 41-14 in 2011 |
| Colorado College | 3-1-0 | W, 35-26 in 1994 |
| Creighton | 1-0-0 | W, 13-7 in 1936 |
| Dallas University | 1-2-0 | W, 89-0 in 1919 |
| Daniel Baker | 15-3-2 | W, 33-0 in 1940 |
| Decatur | 1-0-0 | W, 6-0 in 1928 |
| Denver | 1-0-0 | W, 20-0 in 1946 |
| Dixie | 1-0-0 | W, 17-6 in 1933 |
| East Texas Baptist | 10-1-0 |
L, 26-22 in 2011 |
| East Texas State | 4-0-0 | W, 27-6 in 1938 |
| Emporia State | 1-0-0 | W, 66-6 in 1937 |
| Evangel College | 1-1-0 | L, 45-23 in 1996 |
| Fresno State | 2-0-0 | W, 14-7 in 1937 |
| George Washington | 0-1-0 | L, 13-7 in 1956 |
| Georgia | 0-1-0 | L, 35-6 in 1959 |
| Howard Payne | 34-25-4 | W, 33-14 in 2011 |
| Houston | 2-1-2 | L, 35-27 in 1951 |
| Kansas State | 1-0-0 | W, 21-7 in 1946 |
| Kansas Wesleyan | 1-0-0 | W, 26-0 in 1936 |
| Lambuth College | 0-1-0 | L, 57-54 in 1994 |
| Langston | 1-0-0 | W, 41-0 in 1997 |
| Lindenwood | 0-1-0 | L, 35-17 in 1991 |
| Linfield | 1-2-0 | L, 37-22 in 2009 |
| Louisiana College | 8-2-0 | W, 41-27 in 2011 |
| Louisiana State | 0-1-0 | L, 20-6 in 1958 |
| Loyola (Calif.) | 3-4-0 | L, 14-13 in 1951 |
| Mary | 1-0-0 | W, 30-20 in 1993 |
| Mary Hardin-Baylor | 5-10-0 | L, 35-17 in 2011 |
| McMurry | 25-4-0 | L, 24-14 in 2011 |
| Memphis State | 0-2-0 | L, 56-0 in 1961 |
| Menlo | 1-1-0 | W, 42-34 in 2002 |
| Meridian College | 1-1-0 | W, 38-0 in 1919 |
| Midwestern State | 7-4-0 | L, 34-23 in 1998 |
| Milsaps College | 2-0-0 | W, 55-14 in 1993 |
| Minot State (N.D.) | 0-1-0 | L, 21-14 in 1992 |
| Mississippi | 0-2-0 | L, 24-0 in 1958 |
| Mississippi College | 12-3-0 | L, 45-17 in 2011 |
| Mississippi Southern | 0-1-0 | L, 27-0 in 1960 |
| Mississippi State | 0-1-0 | L, 27-7 in 1947 |
| Missouri Valley | 1-0-0 | W, 49-21 in 1994 |
| Morningside | 2-0-0 | W, 59-0 in 1936 |
| Murray State | 2-0-0 | W, 20-14 in 1938 |
| New Mexico | 4-0-0 | W, 34-7 in 1949 |
| New Mexico Military | 2-0-0 | W, 19-0 in 1922 |
| New Mexico State | 9-5-1 | W, 41-6 in 1963 |
| North Texas | 8-10-1 | L, 18-12 in 1963 |
| Oklahoma Baptist | 1-0-0 | W, 52-0 in 1936 |
| Oklahoma City | 3-0-0 | W, 34-21 in 1948 |
| Ouachita | 2-0-0 | W, 40-12 in 1948 |
| Pacific | 1-1-1 | W, 20-19 in 1956 |
| Panhandle State | 4-0-0 | W, 38-31 in 1999 |
| Phillips | 0-2-0 | L, 9-0 in 1921 |
| Prairie View A&M | 1-0-0 | W, 42-12 in 1996 |
| Rice | 0-1-0 | L, 40-0 in 1953 |
| Saint John's | 0-1-0 | L, 38-14 in 2002 |
| St. Edward's | 5-5-3 | W, 33-3 in 1939 |
| St. Mary's | 1-0-0 | W, 13-2 in 1926 |
| San Diego State | 1-0-0 | W, 53-0 in 1947 |
| San Jose State | 1-1-1 | L, 19-12 in 1947 |
| San Francisco | 1-1-1 | W, 28-18 in 1940 |
| Santa Clara | 0-0-1 | T, 14-14 in 1952 |
| Southern Methodist | 1-3-1 | W, 7-6 in 1942 |
| Southwestern | 5-2-2 | L, 16-6 in 1963 |
| Southwestern (Kan.) | 1-0-0 | W, 35-9 in 1999 |
| SW Louisiana | 0-1-0 | L, 16-6 in 2002 |
| Stephen F. Austin | 1-0-0 | W, 16-6 in 1963 |
| Sul Ross State | 29-2-0 | W, 64-39 in 2011 |
| Tarleton State | 3-7-0 | L, 44-37 in 1993 |
| Texas | 0-2-0 | L, 36-0 in 1936 |
| Texas A&I | 2-0-0 | W, 39-6 in 1936 |
| Texas A&M | 0-1-0 | L, 3-0 in 1936 |
| Texas Christian | 2-8-2 | L, 27-0 in 1932 |
| Texas-El Paso (Western) | 18-10-1 | L, 7-6 in 1962 |
| Texas Lutheran | 11-1-0 | W, 67-17 in 2011 |
| Texas Tech | 7-14-3 | L, 26-21 in 1957 |
| Texas Wesleyan | 1-0-0 | W, 31-7 in 1941 |
| Trinity | 19-6-4 | W, 33-30 in 2000 |
| Tulsa | 3-9-0 | L, 39-0 in 1962 |
| Wayland Baptist | 3-0-0 | W, 40-0 in 1923 |
| Washington | 1-0-0 | W, 28-21 in 1999 |
| Wash. and Jefferson | 1-0-0 | W, 51-3 in 1999 |
| Wesley | 1-0-0 | W, 6-0 in 1920 |
| Western Maryland | 1-0-0 | W, 32-10 in 2000 |
| Western New Mexico | 1-0-0 | W, 33-29 in 1997 |
| Westminster | 0-1-0 | L, 10-0 in 1993 |
| West Texas A&M | 26-10-0 | L, 40-34 in 1994 |
| Whitworth | 2-0-0 | W, 27-7 in 2010 |
| Wichita | 4-3-0 | L, 26-12 in 1963 |
| Williamette | 2-0-0 | W, 30-24 in 2011 |
| Wis.-La Crosse | 0-1-0 | L, 47-21 in 2007 |
| Wis.-Whitewater | 1-0-0 | W, 37-8 in 2000 |
| Wis.-Stevens Point | 2-0-0 | W, 49-17 in 2006 |
| Wis.-Stout | 0-1-0 | L, 31-21 in 2003 |
| Wittenberg | 0-1-0 | L, 38-35 in 2001 |
| Wyoming | 0-1-0 | L, 14-6 in 1958 |